Top 20 Live Recordings?

Evil One · 31 Aug 2010, 19:59

The strange one has done this:

YouTube Video

Which got me thinking. What are your top 20 Meaty live tracks? I think we should only allow a song to appear once, so FCOL and BOOH can't take up most of the spaces.

After some head scratching mine are:

Objects In The Rear View Mirror - Hudson Theater '93
For Crying Out Loud - El Mocambo '77
I'd Do Anything For Love - Hudson Theater '93
All Revved Up - El Mocambo '77
Good Girls Go To Heaven - Live Around The World ??

Two Out Of Three - Wembley '87
Out Of The Frying Pan - MSO '04
Heaven Can Wait - Hudson Theater '93
Bat Out Of Hell - Bad Attitude Live '85
Mercury Blues - MSO '04

Everything Louder - Hudson Theater '93
Modern Girl - Wembley '87
Dead Ringer - Beacon Theater '95
Testify - MSO '04
Blind As A Bat - Norfolk '08

Rock And Roll Dreams - Cardiff '93
I'd Lie For You - TMF Concert '98
You Took The Words - Hammersmith Odeon '78
Nowhere Fast - Bad Attitude Live '85
Amnesty Is Granted - Berlin '08

Wario · 01 Sep 2010, 03:19

Comparing my list to your list is unjust.

You tend to look at the soundboards that have been officially released (or radio oriented).

My favorites, as in the video of mine you posted, are abstract.

You tend to dislike recordings that aren't soundboard sourced. I look for the great performance and bearability of the recording.

You look for the great performance, as long as its Soundboard approved.

Dusseldorf 1999, Birmingham 1988, Sheffield 1987, Glasgow 1983, and Hammersmith odeon 1985 may not be soundboard quality but the shows themselves are great and audio is excellent. You can tell whats going on.

Then again, i have a far superior collection of recordings then most on here. and Im also familiar with every show I have.

I made hard choices. Meats been supporting my channel recently and I added the LA from Houston to suffice. Its a great performance, but Midnight from Birmingham 1988 is far superior.

Officially, Like E1 did it, Itd go:

Objects - Hudson Tehater
BOOH - BA Live
FCOL - MSO
Rock & Roll Dreams - Cardiff 1993
CHSIB - MSO
Paradise - MSO
Modern Girl - Wembley 1987
Frying Pan - LATW
2 outta 3 - Rockpalast 1978
Louder/DRFL medley - Cardiff, 1993
Midnight - Wembley 1987 (alternate version played on radio)
Lemon - Cardiff 1993
All Revved Up - BA Live
Masculine - Live Rehearsal 1993
What you See Is What You Get - LATW / NYC 1995
POTA - BA Live
Blind Before I Stop - Wembley 1987
Jumping the Gun - BA Live
Execution Day - Meltdown 1987
Break It - HCTB Live CD

AndrewG · 01 Sep 2010, 08:10

Wario, that was your most pompous sounding post yet.

Evil One · 01 Sep 2010, 15:26

I think Wario must have a pretty poor audio setup.

AndrewG · 01 Sep 2010, 15:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evil One

I think Wario must have a pretty poor audio setup.

Maybe, but then he has a far superior collection than you have so you know nothing anyway.

Wario · 01 Sep 2010, 17:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndrewG

Maybe, but then he has a far superior collection than you have so you know nothing anyway.

Exactly

(that actually came out a little wrong. I meant I have more love for audience recordings then he does. and with all them included, my collection is broader).

Though im surprised all his favs are official. thats what i was trying to say...

AndrewG · 01 Sep 2010, 17:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by WarioLoaf

Exactly

(that actually came out a little wrong. I meant I have more love for audience recordings then he does. and with all them included, my collection is broader).

Though im surprised all his favs are official. thats what i was trying to say...

I guessed that but it was funny anyway.

Evil One · 01 Sep 2010, 18:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by WarioLoaf

Exactly

(that actually came out a little wrong. I meant I have more love for audience recordings then he does. and with all them included, my collection is broader).

Are you sure? You don't know the extent of my collection.

Quote:

Originally Posted by WarioLoaf

Though im surprised all his favs are official. thats what i was trying to say...

There is something to be said for sound quality. Putting a tatty audience recording on the stereo at full whack doesn't have the same effect as the real McCoy or a decent bootleg from a radio broadcast. That said, there's nothing wrong with audience recordings for the sake of curiousity.

Wario · 01 Sep 2010, 22:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evil One

Are you sure? You don't know the extent of my collection.

Or do I muahahahahaaa

01 Sep 2010, 03:19	#2
Wario Monstro helps me spell things... Join Date: 05.01.2007 Location: Masculine, Pennsylvania Posts: 9,105	Comparing my list to your list is unjust. You tend to look at the soundboards that have been officially released (or radio oriented). My favorites, as in the video of mine you posted, are abstract. You tend to dislike recordings that aren't soundboard sourced. I look for the great performance and bearability of the recording. You look for the great performance, as long as its Soundboard approved. Dusseldorf 1999, Birmingham 1988, Sheffield 1987, Glasgow 1983, and Hammersmith odeon 1985 may not be soundboard quality but the shows themselves are great and audio is excellent. You can tell whats going on. Then again, i have a far superior collection of recordings then most on here. and Im also familiar with every show I have. I made hard choices. Meats been supporting my channel recently and I added the LA from Houston to suffice. Its a great performance, but Midnight from Birmingham 1988 is far superior. Officially, Like E1 did it, Itd go: Objects - Hudson Tehater BOOH - BA Live FCOL - MSO Rock & Roll Dreams - Cardiff 1993 CHSIB - MSO Paradise - MSO Modern Girl - Wembley 1987 Frying Pan - LATW 2 outta 3 - Rockpalast 1978 Louder/DRFL medley - Cardiff, 1993 Midnight - Wembley 1987 (alternate version played on radio) Lemon - Cardiff 1993 All Revved Up - BA Live Masculine - Live Rehearsal 1993 What you See Is What You Get - LATW / NYC 1995 POTA - BA Live Blind Before I Stop - Wembley 1987 Jumping the Gun - BA Live Execution Day - Meltdown 1987 Break It - HCTB Live CD

01 Sep 2010, 08:10	#3
AndrewG I hope your salmon sucks! Join Date: 18.01.2004 Location: Northamptonshire Posts: 7,077	Wario, that was your most pompous sounding post yet.

01 Sep 2010, 15:26	#4
Evil One Mega Loafer Join Date: 15.01.2007 Posts: 5,192	I think Wario must have a pretty poor audio setup.