3 Bats Live: Bad For Good REEDITED - Page 3

Wario · 24 Sep 2010, 02:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndrewG

So you don't agree with Steve6 who thinks that the drums on Jim's BFG sucked and sound like pots and pans? I don't get what he is on about to be honest. I love the instrumentation and drum sound on Jim's whole album. For 1981 it's a fantastic production that still sounds modern to this day imo.

but its went the way of the dodo cause of money, ego, jealousy, stress, anger, and friendship (the six emotional lusts)

Evil One · 24 Sep 2010, 09:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sarge

Let's assume you had unlimited means to re-record Bad For Good. What would a perfect version of it sound like?

Jim's original arrangement, a Pandora's Box style sound and some top quality vocals from Meat.

Evil One · 24 Sep 2010, 09:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by WarioLoaf

mercury's weakest moment was on the 3 Bats DVD. I really think it was unnecessary.

What exactly is wrong with it, apart from it not being as good as the MSO performance?

Wario · 24 Sep 2010, 14:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by Evil One

What exactly is wrong with it, apart from it not being as good as the MSO performance?

I just think theirs something a little "watery" about the drums and think it was a little outta place

Steve6 · 25 Sep 2010, 14:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndrewG

So you don't agree with Steve6 who thinks that the drums on Jim's BFG sucked and sound like pots and pans? I don't get what he is on about to be honest. I love the instrumentation and drum sound on Jim's whole album. For 1981 it's a fantastic production that still sounds modern to this day imo.

It's just how it sounded to me. I like Jim's version of BFG better than the one on BAT 3, but yeah the drums did sound like pots and pans. I thought it could have been better, but others may think different. Meat does a good job but I'm disappointed they got rid of the "Godspeed" part in the song.

Sue K · 25 Sep 2010, 17:35

I like Steinman's version of BFG. When I heard Meat was putting it on Bat3, I admit, I wondered if I would like it as much, but Meat took it on and I'm well pleased with the results. I like Meat's version more than Steinman's, but like Steinman's still.

Now, Left In The Dark ? Sorry. Steinman's I can't listen to. It's painful to me, but Meat's version is one of my all time favorite songs.

All imo.

25 Sep 2010, 17:35	#56
Sue K Mega Loafer Join Date: 20.04.2003 Posts: 13,041	I like Steinman's version of BFG. When I heard Meat was putting it on Bat3, I admit, I wondered if I would like it as much, but Meat took it on and I'm well pleased with the results. I like Meat's version more than Steinman's, but like Steinman's still. Now, Left In The Dark ? Sorry. Steinman's I can't listen to. It's painful to me, but Meat's version is one of my all time favorite songs. All imo.