There was an extended version of Everything is Permitted?

[Steve6]

Originally Posted by Pudding

There'd be the same lyrics and the notes would have been in the same order, no matter who produced it it would still be shit.

I disagree with that Pudding. If Jim was in the studio he would have changed things he's done so in the past. But really the answer is "We will never know". I mean look at the difference between Bonnie Tylers TEOTH and Westlife's!!! He tweaks things you can't say he doesn't. He would have taken Everything is Permitted to a new level.

[Evil One]

But would it have been a higher or lower level? Look at Frying Pan on Bat 2 as an example.

[Pudding]

Originally Posted by Steve6

I disagree with that Pudding.

There's a shocker

Originally Posted by Steve6

I mean look at the difference between Bonnie Tylers TEOTH and Westlife's!!!

You can tell it's the same song though can't you? I mean the notes and the lyrics are EXACTLY the same even if the production is different.

I respect the fact that some people may like/dislike certain versions of songs and some people (like me in this instance) just doesn't like the song full stop. I don't like the song.

You can polish a turd as nice as you want, but it's still a turd.

[Steve6]

Originally Posted by Pudding

There's a shocker

You can tell it's the same song though can't you? I mean the notes and the lyrics are EXACTLY the same even if the production is different.

I respect the fact that some people may like/dislike certain versions of songs and some people (like me in this instance) just doesn't like the song full stop. I don't like the song.

You can polish a turd as nice as you want, but it's still a turd.

I still disgree. Look at Meat Loaf's version of "Forever Young" on CHSIB, it has a completely different sound to Bob Dylans version. I mean the only thing that's the same is the lyrics. If both songs were released into the charts at the same time, they would have faired out a hell of a lot differently.

[Pudding]

Originally Posted by Steve6

I still disgree.

Whatever fella

[Steve6]

Originally Posted by Pudding

Whatever fella

Thanks Pudding. I'm still convinced Jimmy could have given you a version of "Everything is Permitted" that you would have loved. Maybe he still will.

[Pudding]

Originally Posted by Steve6

I'm still convinced Jimmy could have given you a version of "Everything is Permitted" that you would have loved.

And I'm convinced that he wouldn't.