Stripped down bat

duke knooby · 10 Feb 2006, 20:53

Anyone else love to here bat rerecorded in a stripped down format, just piano and voices, jim and meat, like the rehersals must have been????

L96 · 10 Feb 2006, 21:14

Nope.

It just wouldn't be the same without the guitar/motorbike effects.

Bart · 10 Feb 2006, 22:55

Yes.

Because it wouldn't be the same without the guitar/motorbikes effects.
I think it would be awesome. Meat and Jim just like the rehearsed. yes, that is magic.

Pudding · 11 Feb 2006, 00:10

I'm fairly certain that when Meat and Jim were rehearsing Bat Out Of Hell in the hotel back in 1976 they didn't use any motorbike sound effects.

If Bat Out Of Hell was ever to get stripped down to just a piano and an acoustic guitar, then Roy Bittan would definitel have to be the one on the piano and not Steinman...IMO

Pud

duke knooby · 11 Feb 2006, 00:40

pud what is it about bittans skills that you prefer, i thought roy was meant to be similar in style to james

Pudding · 11 Feb 2006, 01:43

Jim Steinman might be an amazing songwriter, but even Steinman's admitted Roy Bittan is better than what he is. Some people think Steinman is the best thing since sliced bread on everything he does, but the truth is, his singing sucks and his piano playing could be better.

If you listen to some of Steinman's most awesome songs, then take a look at who's on the piano, it's a safe bet the name Roy Bittan will pop up and not Jim Steinman.

Pud

Ben · 11 Feb 2006, 19:18

i think that the whole bat album would sound great like that!!

PanicLord · 14 Feb 2006, 13:04

Wasn't Jim talking also about a Bat Out Of Nashville, with all the songs countryfied up? Now that would be good. I don't think stripped down would necessarily work, as part of the fun is the massive productions - worth a try though, you never know!

firstbase · 17 Feb 2006, 21:54

I once had a friend who did an amazing version of Bat with just him and an accoustic guitar. OK so it's not the big man himself but it was pretty good nonetheless

FWIW

Mark
http://www.fromparadisetohell.com

Rockette · 19 Feb 2006, 01:17

There are plenty of Meat's songs that could be performed *unplugged*, but Bat just isn't one of them. Strip it down and it just isn't Bat anymore.

duke knooby · 19 Feb 2006, 02:17

oops, meant the whole album, however, i'd love to hear a more rock sound to some of the songs, more guitars and less background vocals, but ive drifted off topic. is it me or does meat sing much better/ more powerfully with a low voice?

Rockette · 19 Feb 2006, 03:59

Absolutely! I love the way he's allowing his maturing voice to open up. There is nothing more ludicrous than hearing a maturing singer attempting the same notes they were able to strike quite well in their 20s. It's demeaning to their own capabilities.

As far as returning to your original question. Sorry, I went off topic to the degree that I read BOOH *the song* rather than BOOH *the album*. But I still stick with my original post's intent. BOOH *the song* - no way without the guitars and motorbikes, etc., but certainly there are a lot of the other tracks that could lend themselves to a stripped down version I believe.

10 Feb 2006, 20:53	#1
duke knooby Mega Loafer Join Date: 24.06.2005 Location: belfast Posts: 17,909	Stripped down bat Anyone else love to here bat rerecorded in a stripped down format, just piano and voices, jim and meat, like the rehersals must have been????

10 Feb 2006, 21:14	#2
L96 Inaugural goldfish winner Join Date: 04.07.2005 Location: In a handbasket. Believe me, for someone my height, it's hell... Posts: 2,373	Nope. It just wouldn't be the same without the guitar/motorbike effects.

10 Feb 2006, 22:55	#3
Bart Bald Mega Loafer Join Date: 06.03.2003 Location: Holland, but I prefer Greece Posts: 2,243	Yes. Because it wouldn't be the same without the guitar/motorbikes effects. I think it would be awesome. Meat and Jim just like the rehearsed. yes, that is magic.

11 Feb 2006, 00:10	#4
Pudding I'm A Prize Fight Lover... Join Date: 22.10.2003 Location: New Zealand Posts: 5,532	I'm fairly certain that when Meat and Jim were rehearsing Bat Out Of Hell in the hotel back in 1976 they didn't use any motorbike sound effects. If Bat Out Of Hell was ever to get stripped down to just a piano and an acoustic guitar, then Roy Bittan would definitel have to be the one on the piano and not Steinman...IMO Pud

11 Feb 2006, 00:40	#5
duke knooby Mega Loafer Join Date: 24.06.2005 Location: belfast Posts: 17,909	pud what is it about bittans skills that you prefer, i thought roy was meant to be similar in style to james

11 Feb 2006, 01:43	#6
Pudding I'm A Prize Fight Lover... Join Date: 22.10.2003 Location: New Zealand Posts: 5,532	Jim Steinman might be an amazing songwriter, but even Steinman's admitted Roy Bittan is better than what he is. Some people think Steinman is the best thing since sliced bread on everything he does, but the truth is, his singing sucks and his piano playing could be better. If you listen to some of Steinman's most awesome songs, then take a look at who's on the piano, it's a safe bet the name Roy Bittan will pop up and not Jim Steinman. Pud

11 Feb 2006, 19:18	#7
Ben Mega Loafer Join Date: 19.03.2003 Location: Kent, England Posts: 4,163	i think that the whole bat album would sound great like that!!

14 Feb 2006, 13:04	#8
PanicLord Mega Loafer Join Date: 18.06.2003 Location: At The End Of The Line Posts: 2,654	Wasn't Jim talking also about a Bat Out Of Nashville, with all the songs countryfied up? Now that would be good. I don't think stripped down would necessarily work, as part of the fun is the massive productions - worth a try though, you never know!

17 Feb 2006, 21:54	#9
firstbase Junior Loafer Join Date: 17.11.2004 Location: St. Albans Posts: 26	I once had a friend who did an amazing version of Bat with just him and an accoustic guitar. OK so it's not the big man himself but it was pretty good nonetheless FWIW Mark http://www.fromparadisetohell.com

19 Feb 2006, 01:17	#10
Rockette Mega Loafer Join Date: 10.06.2005 Location: I think! Posts: 4,805	There are plenty of Meat's songs that could be performed unplugged, but Bat just isn't one of them. Strip it down and it just isn't Bat anymore.

19 Feb 2006, 02:17	#11
duke knooby Mega Loafer Join Date: 24.06.2005 Location: belfast Posts: 17,909	oops, meant the whole album, however, i'd love to hear a more rock sound to some of the songs, more guitars and less background vocals, but ive drifted off topic. is it me or does meat sing much better/ more powerfully with a low voice?

19 Feb 2006, 03:59	#12
Rockette Mega Loafer Join Date: 10.06.2005 Location: I think! Posts: 4,805	Absolutely! I love the way he's allowing his maturing voice to open up. There is nothing more ludicrous than hearing a maturing singer attempting the same notes they were able to strike quite well in their 20s. It's demeaning to their own capabilities. As far as returning to your original question. Sorry, I went off topic to the degree that I read BOOH the song rather than BOOH the album. But I still stick with my original post's intent. BOOH the song - no way without the guitars and motorbikes, etc., but certainly there are a lot of the other tracks that could lend themselves to a stripped down version I believe.