Who's Your Favorite Guitar Player?

[BostonAngel]

So many good ones. Mick Mars from Motley Crue would probably be my #1. Slash, Santana, Randy, Paul, Brian May, Jimi Hendrix...

[Tri.somethin]

David Gilmour.

[Julie in the rv mirror]

Originally Posted by Tri.somethin

David Gilmour.

The guitar solo in Comfortably Numb is probably one of the best in rock (IMO):

YouTube Video

As a side note, I just read that Roger Waters is supposedly bringing The Wall to stadiums next year, including Wrigley Field in Chicago. I think that's awesome- I'd love to see it again. I read they are going to triple the size of the wall!

Come on, guys- let's see some more. Video, too!

[Julie in the rv mirror]

Here's a pretty nice video of Nils doing the tap dance- pretty interesting!

Dream Big

YouTube Video

And Shine Silently from the same show- I love the spin!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2FXmZ...eature=related

[Sarge]

I've never seen anybody dance while playing harp. Cool.

[duke knooby]

Originally Posted by Sarge

I've never seen anybody dance while playing harp. Cool.

ive never seen a harp quite that shape, and never seen one played from that side

[AndyK]

Considering the guy has had two hip replacements it's incredible!

[Julie in the rv mirror]

I thought I might post this here again, as I think it's relevant to this thread. I'd planned on posting it here originally, but Wario beat me to it.

Here's Rolling Stone's current list of the 100 Greatest Guitar Players of all time. http://www.rollingstone.com/music/li...rists-20111123

Now, these things are always somewhat subjective, but I thought it would be interesting to see where some of our favorites ended up, if they were on the list at all.

1) Jimi Hendrix (naturally)
2) Eric Clapton
3) Jimmy Page
4) Keith Richards
5) Jeff Beck
6) B.B. King
8 ) Eddie Van Halen
12) Stevie Ray Vaughan
14) David Gilmour
20) Carlos Santana
22) Frank Zappa
23) Buddy Guy
25) Tony Iommi
26) Brian May
33) Prince
36) Randy Rhoads
57) Rory Gallagher
65) Slash

Only 2 ladies made the list: Joni Mitchell at #75, and Bonnie Raitt at #89.

I can't argue with some on the list, especially the top ten, but some choices I'd beg to differ with, as we all would, I suppose.

No Nils Lofgren, Peter Frampton, or Steve Vai, surprisingly. I was also surprised that Springsteen made the list this time, albeit at #96, because he's usually overlooked on these things.

Thoughts?

[lyn]

Originally Posted by Julie in the rv mirror

I thought I might post this here again, as I think it's relevant to this thread. I'd planned on posting it here originally, but Wario beat me to it.

Here's Rolling Stone's current list of the 100 Greatest Guitar Players of all time. http://www.rollingstone.com/music/li...rists-20111123

Now, these things are always somewhat subjective, but I thought it would be interesting to see where some of our favorites ended up, if they were on the list at all.

1) Jimi Hendrix (naturally)
2) Eric Clapton
3) Jimmy Page
4) Keith Richards
5) Jeff Beck
6) B.B. King
8 ) Eddie Van Halen
12) Stevie Ray Vaughan
14) David Gilmour
20) Carlos Santana
22) Frank Zappa
23) Buddy Guy
25) Tony Iommi
26) Brian May
33) Prince
36) Randy Rhoads
57) Rory Gallagher
65) Slash

Only 2 ladies made the list: Joni Mitchell at #75, and Bonnie Raitt at #89.

I can't argue with some on the list, especially the top ten, but some choices I'd beg to differ with, as we all would, I suppose.

No Nils Lofgren, Peter Frampton, or Steve Vai, surprisingly. I was also surprised that Springsteen made the list this time, albeit at #96, because he's usually overlooked on these things.

Thoughts?

Pretty impressive lol I'm quite surprised that Slash is that low on the list. I'll have to go to the link and have a proper look, as I do love Richie Sambora from Bon Jovi, so before making any other judgement lol, I shall look at the link :) Thanks for the great post too

[lyn]

Quite surprised by the list. A lot there that I didn't know, then others there that I do, but aren't as ranked high as I thought. Hehehe, some of the older generation ones I remember learning about back in high school in the 1990's.

I'm quite surprised though, and I can't remember his name either, but the other guitarist from Metallica isn't listed at all. Ritchie Sambora didn't get a mention, but I didn't think he really would either. Great to see my hero, Eric Clapton up at No.2 That is where he belongs, if not No.1 :) AC/DC's Angus, well it was good to see him in the position he was in, but could of been a bit higher imo. I kinda hoped an Aussie guitarist by the name of Tommy Emmanuel may of been in the top 100, but didn't hold my breath as I thought he wouldn't be. Willie Nelson, well it was great to see he got in the hundred :) Brian May probably could have been shot up the list a bit more as he is quite a talent. Lead man off Metallica, well he is great but he too could have been bumped up a bit higher on the list due to his ability.

Overall, the top 100 is quite impressive, and I agree with most of the ones that have been posted. Quite a shame to not see more females there, but I suppose that is how it goes with the industry.

[lyn]

Originally Posted by Julie in the rv mirror

If you have one?

And I don't mean your favorite artist overall, or the one that you think has the best technical skills, although that can (and probably will) come into play. But I think style and feeling are just as, if not more important, than technical skill. I'd like to know who you most like to watch and/ or listen to, and why? And give me an example of what you consider to be some of their best work.

For example, I think Eddie Van Halen has (had?) fantastic skills- he's (was) amazingly fast, but there's not much melody to his playing. Eric Clapton is just sublime to listen to, IMO, but kind of boring to watch - he mostly just stands and plays.

My favorite guitarist at the present is Keith Urban. This guy is a rocker in a country singer's body, though I'd consider his music more pop/rock than country. I love his solos- there's an "atmospheric" quality about them that reminds me of David Gilmour. I've seen him live twice, most recently last Friday night, and I think he's just amazing. I had a hard time picking just one song of his to post- I like them all! lol So, I picked a couple:

'Til Summer Comes Around- The song that got me hooked on Keith when I first heard him play it live. I think the treadmill's kind of corny and totally unnecessary, but if anything, the fact that he can walk and play at the same time is kind of impressive:



Raining on Sunday- I love the slower pace on this one, the bluesy intro, and I like the melody on the closing solo: (skip the end with him reading the signs, unless you really want to watch. lol)



He's no slouch on the acoustic, either, and I do love his singing voice:



Another little factoid to mention here is that Randy Flowers' brother, Jerry, plays bass (and other instruments) in Keith's band. You can see him in the ROS video- he's the bald guy on Keith's left (right side of video).


So, who's your guitar hero?

Awwww, now you're talking lol :) Keith Urban is really great too, and not saying that to be biased or anything. But I do love his style :)

[Julie in the rv mirror]

Originally Posted by lyn

Quite surprised by the list. A lot there that I didn't know, then others there that I do, but aren't as ranked high as I thought. Hehehe, some of the older generation ones I remember learning about back in high school in the 1990's. [...]

Yeah, it's an interesting selection. There are many that I don't know, either. As I said, these lists are always somewhat subjective, and we could all make a case for our favorites.

High school in the '90's? Oy, I feel old!

[melon]

Angus Young, Randy Flowers, Paul Crook & Brian May

[smithsleonardo]

My favourite guitar player is Joe Satriani. It is the great Guitarist in our country . I love his bands song and his style of guitar. He makes awesome tunes.

[lyn]

Originally Posted by Julie in the rv mirror

Yeah, it's an interesting selection. There are many that I don't know, either. As I said, these lists are always somewhat subjective, and we could all make a case for our favorites.

High school in the '90's? Oy, I feel old!

Yeah I didn't think there'd be such a variety there, but I suppose they had to make it that way. Hey, your not old lol , just wise :)

[lyn]

Originally Posted by smithsleonardo

My favourite guitar player is Joe Satriani. It is the great Guitarist in our country . I love his bands song and his style of guitar. He makes awesome tunes.

Gosh, how embarressed am I to say that I haven't listen to him much at all I think I need to broaden my horizon a bit when it comes to guitarists mate

Originally Posted by melon

Angus Young, Randy Flowers, Paul Crook & Brian May

Aw yes Paul Crook and Brian May are great

[samurai7]

In no particular order:

Pete Townshend - This guy is to guitar what Jim Steinman is to piano. Thunderous power chords, and a fervent style of playing, though whilst not the most technical, has an amazing effect on the listener. And I've ben lucky enough to see The Who a few times now.

Brian May - The most instantly recognisable sound of any guitarist. Rightly lauded as one of the world's greatest, in my opinion.

George Harrison - I don't suppose I need to say much about this choice!

Prince - Seriously awesome. Should rank much higher in this sort of poll in my opinion. Saw him perform at the O2 Arena a few years back, and was absolutely blown away by his musicianship!

David Gilmour - Again, not much that needs saying.

Chuck Berry - If it wasn't for this guy... etc etc

Mark Knoplfler - Again, seems like an obvious choice, but rightly so in my opinion.

Eric Clapton - As above.

Joe Perry - Was fortunate enough to see him live last year when he was support to Bad Company. Very very good. Also helps that I'm a huge Aerosmith fan too, of course!

Albert Lee - Again, another I've been fortunate enough to see live, this time as part of Bill Wyman's Rhythm Kings. Incredible talent.

Joe Walsh - In my opinion, his joining the Eagles was a masterstroke. Life In The Fast Lane is one of my all-time favourite songs, and without Joe's guitar who knows what it might have been? Life's Been Good, In The City, Pretty Maids all in a Row. The 'duel' with Don Felder at the end of Hotel California is sublime. And yes, I've seen him live too (as part of The Eagles)

Gary Moore - Even if just for Parisienne Walkways and Still Got the Blues!

I'm sure I'll think of about twenty more once I click 'submit reply'

edit: here's a couple...

Slash - Sweet Child O' Mine has been my ringtone since phones first had the capacity to use sound files. It's still one of THE best intros to a song EVER, in my opinion. Anything from Appetite or Use Your Illusion 1/2 is head and shoulders above anything else in their genre.

Robert Johnson - same reason as Chuck Berry

edit 2: and a couple more...

Jimi Hendrix - Electrifying

Jimmy Page - Self explanatory, really

[samurai7]

can we have a thread about worst guitarists? No. 1 - The Edge

[Julie in the rv mirror]

Originally Posted by samurai7

Prince - Seriously awesome. Should rank much higher in this sort of poll in my opinion. Saw him perform at the O2 Arena a few years back, and was absolutely blown away by his musicianship!

Yep; he's not a name that I think many people immediately think of as a great guitarist, but I agree he's fantastic. This solo just blew ne away the first time I saw it (love his exit, lol):

YouTube Video

Originally Posted by samurai7

Chuck Berry - If it wasn't for this guy... etc etc

Absolutely- the guy practically invented Rock'n Roll Still performs, too.

I love this performance from a few years back when he played with the E Street Band. Check out the grin on Bruce's face. lol

YouTube Video

That wasn't the first time they had played together- great story here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGkQk5BuASM

Originally Posted by samurai7

Joe Walsh - In my opinion, his joining the Eagles was a masterstroke. Life In The Fast Lane is one of my all-time favourite songs, and without Joe's guitar who knows what it might have been? Life's Been Good, In The City, Pretty Maids all in a Row. The 'duel' with Don Felder at the end of Hotel California is sublime. And yes, I've seen him live too (as part of The Eagles)

Yep- saw Joe with the Eagles as well, and he pretty much made the show, IMO. In the City was a goosebump moment for me that night.

[samurai7]

Forgot to add Steve Lukather

[duke knooby]

i'd never heard of this guy until today...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLKgO3ZiQH0

i think he's pretty good, what do you guitar lovers reckon??

[Julie in the rv mirror]

Originally Posted by duke knooby

i'd never heard of this guy until today...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLKgO3ZiQH0

i think he's pretty good, what do you guitar lovers reckon??

Wow, he's awesome! He looks pretty young, too; he reminds me of this kid- I think he's about 12 here:

YouTube Video

I wish I could read all those sigs on his guitar.

[duke knooby]

that kids guitar is very like mine... only he can play it better

[Julie in the rv mirror]

Originally Posted by duke knooby

that kids guitar is very like mine... only he can play it better

Do you have autographs on yours, too? If so, who have ya got?

Speaking of guitars, I thought this story was totally cool:

http://artsbeat.blogs.nytimes.com/20...fter-31-years/

[Julie in the rv mirror]

I just had to bump this thread to add this video- a dream pretty much came true for me last Friday night. Bruce used to play this song with this long intro back in 1978, and the first time I heard it on a bootleg, I was absolutely floored. I always wished he'd do it this way again, but didn't think it would ever happen, especially after Bruce himself said he probably never would. Well, something made him change his mind, and he started playing it again this tour, so I had hopes he would play it at one of the shows I saw last week. Not only did he play it, he opened with it, and it was pretty incredible! I'm still pinching myself.

YouTube Video