A Fanmade Music Video - Page 2

mszee · 05 Dec 2006, 15:22

I must be insane...but I actually thought that Pud's input was a positive one???

Alright, it's a proven fact that I am insane...

I would re-read his original post again and take it into consideration. He gave a decent idea to a creative mind...if I was told this, I would have run out and tried exactly what he suggested...

mcquaidbros · 06 Dec 2006, 01:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pudding

Choose a piece of music you really like and images or clips from video's you really like and give it another go.

Pud

ok as I look at your comment again, I'm confused...I thought that is what I did. I like the music and the videos I put together...so could you show me, in your opinion, an original fan vid?

Pudding · 06 Dec 2006, 01:47

Your idea was based on a pre-existing one.
To quote me a bit too similar to the other TMIL video that Meats record company brought out. and your reply Pudding, that was kind of the point...

An original piece would be something like the music of BAAB to just the Bat music videos, or the music of Seize The Night to just the Steinman related music video's Meat sings, or the music of Alive to Meats movies. Something like that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mszee

I must be insane...but I actually thought that Pud's input was a positive one???

That's all it ever was

Pud

Paul191 · 07 Dec 2006, 03:03

I can see how mcquaidbros thought your comments were negative Pud but, to be honest I think too many people are hurt easily in this day and age. They do something and expect a barrage of compliments........... Even if what they did was s**t.

If people could just learn from negative criticism then they would learn so much more, hence, turning it into postive criticism. If you started saying "Oh I love your video........ It's awesome.... I wish I could f**k it" then mcquaidbros would be happy but nothing would be learned.

However, if I was to give my opinion on the video..... I would say it was good.

Rockette · 07 Dec 2006, 04:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul191

I can see how mcquaidbros thought your comments were negative Pud but, to be honest I think too many people are hurt easily in this day and age. They do something and expect a barrage of compliments........... Even if what they did was s**t.
If people could just learn from negative criticism then they would learn so much more, hence, turning it into postive criticism. If you started saying "Oh I love your video........ It's awesome.... I wish I could f**k it" then mcquaidbros would be happy but nothing would be learned.
However, if I was to give my opinion on the video..... I would say it was good.

Artists in general are sensitive by nature, which leaves them open to being hurt. When we are shown something, and/or asked an opinion, that opinion should be neither negative nor positive criticism, but "constructive" criticism. I have been both negatively criticised and constructively criticised for my creative work. Infinitely more was learned from the constructive criticism, that included some considered admendments. The negative criticism (for which I had paid) left me nothing with which I could work.

Pud's constructive criticism was helpful in my opinion. Mcquaidbros, you've got this video (and probably others, I would venture) about 95% right. If you put some or all of Pud's suggestions into action, you have a real talent worth promoting.

mcquaidbros · 07 Dec 2006, 04:41

Rockette, I've done more videos, located at my You Tube acct.

Also, I can understand Pudding's first post now that he explained himself (to me) a bit more clearly in later posts. I still like how I did my video, but thank you, Pudding, for your imput.

Rockette · 07 Dec 2006, 04:53

Just be it known that I'm blind as a bat when it comes to finding my way around the Net.

I've bookmarked your account now and will take a long look at it later, when time permits.

mcquaidbros · 07 Dec 2006, 04:58

If you need help, ask me. There isn't any Meat stuff there, other than this vid...but someone has asked me to make them a video, so when I get that one finished it will be posted.

Paul191 · 07 Dec 2006, 13:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockette

Artists in general are sensitive by nature, which leaves them open to being hurt. When we are shown something, and/or asked an opinion, that opinion should be neither negative nor positive criticism, but "constructive" criticism. I have been both negatively criticised and constructively criticised for my creative work. Infinitely more was learned from the constructive criticism, that included some considered admendments. The negative criticism (for which I had paid) left me nothing with which I could work.

Pud's constructive criticism was helpful in my opinion. Mcquaidbros, you've got this video (and probably others, I would venture) about 95% right. If you put some or all of Pud's suggestions into action, you have a real talent worth promoting.

Don't think your telling me something I don't already know. My point was that Puddings posts were constructive............. I simply stated that they could easily be missinterpretated as negative criticism............ Saying that, criticism has to be negative or positive. It can't be anything else........ It's only constructive if someone learns from it.

Pudding · 08 Dec 2006, 00:01

I've just been messing around on Youtube and spotted a fan video that I thought was quite well done. Not sure if its already been posted on here or if the person is a member on here but I liked it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSkJbA0bO30

Pud

Caelan · 08 Dec 2006, 00:39

love it ..thanks for the find Pud..

sunneke · 08 Dec 2006, 09:26

this is indeed a great vid. thanks Pud!

Caelan · 08 Dec 2006, 10:29

I even found myself in it..whoohoo

MeatGrl1 · 08 Dec 2006, 12:26

I have seen this before.

It's fantastic and brings back so many wonderful memories

.

*AndyK* · 08 Dec 2006, 13:29

Therte's quite a few familiar faces crop up in the audience shots if you look closely ...

Lord Kagan · 08 Dec 2006, 18:29

Decent effort

05 Dec 2006, 15:22	#26
mszee Mega Loafer Join Date: 29.03.2006 Location: And you think you're down under??? Posts: 26,252	I must be insane...but I actually thought that Pud's input was a positive one??? Alright, it's a proven fact that I am insane... I would re-read his original post again and take it into consideration. He gave a decent idea to a creative mind...if I was told this, I would have run out and tried exactly what he suggested...

07 Dec 2006, 03:03	#29
Paul191 Mega Loafer Join Date: 26.11.2005 Location: Posts: 1,530	I can see how mcquaidbros thought your comments were negative Pud but, to be honest I think too many people are hurt easily in this day and age. They do something and expect a barrage of compliments........... Even if what they did was st. If people could just learn from negative criticism then they would learn so much more, hence, turning it into postive criticism. If you started saying "Oh I love your video........ It's awesome.... I wish I could fk it" then mcquaidbros would be happy but nothing would be learned. However, if I was to give my opinion on the video..... I would say it was good.

07 Dec 2006, 04:41	#31
mcquaidbros Junior Loafer Join Date: 26.10.2006 Posts: 43	Rockette, I've done more videos, located at my You Tube acct. Also, I can understand Pudding's first post now that he explained himself (to me) a bit more clearly in later posts. I still like how I did my video, but thank you, Pudding, for your imput.

07 Dec 2006, 04:53	#32
Rockette Mega Loafer Join Date: 10.06.2005 Location: I think! Posts: 4,805	Just be it known that I'm blind as a bat when it comes to finding my way around the Net. I've bookmarked your account now and will take a long look at it later, when time permits.

07 Dec 2006, 04:58	#33
mcquaidbros Junior Loafer Join Date: 26.10.2006 Posts: 43	If you need help, ask me. There isn't any Meat stuff there, other than this vid...but someone has asked me to make them a video, so when I get that one finished it will be posted.

08 Dec 2006, 00:01	#35
Pudding I'm A Prize Fight Lover... Join Date: 22.10.2003 Location: New Zealand Posts: 5,532	I've just been messing around on Youtube and spotted a fan video that I thought was quite well done. Not sure if its already been posted on here or if the person is a member on here but I liked it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSkJbA0bO30 Pud

08 Dec 2006, 00:39	#36
Caelan life is one big adventure Join Date: 23.06.2005 Location: some town in Alberta called Leduc Posts: 5,550	love it ..thanks for the find Pud..

08 Dec 2006, 09:26	#37
sunneke Mega Loafer Join Date: 17.01.2006 Location: Amersfoort Posts: 2,263	this is indeed a great vid. thanks Pud!

08 Dec 2006, 10:29	#38
Caelan life is one big adventure Join Date: 23.06.2005 Location: some town in Alberta called Leduc Posts: 5,550	I even found myself in it..whoohoo

08 Dec 2006, 12:26	#39
MeatGrl1 No Day But Today Join Date: 29.05.2006 Location: Sitting on the steps outside looking so restless and reckless and lost! Posts: 9,089	I have seen this before. It's fantastic and brings back so many wonderful memories .

08 Dec 2006, 13:29	#40
AndyK Relentless Join Date: 21.11.2003 Location: Over the top..... seeing what's on the other side Posts: 18,694	Therte's quite a few familiar faces crop up in the audience shots if you look closely ...

08 Dec 2006, 18:29	#41
Lord Kagan On the other hand, You have different fingers Join Date: 17.05.2006 Location: Belfast Posts: 8,833	Decent effort