Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Michel
Most people gave the songs 10/10. I can't understand how they can give FCOL a 10/10 and YRIWW a 10/10
|
to digress slightly...
Have to agree with you there.....for crying out loud is a powerful emotional song, my favourite so i would give it a10/10
You're right i was wrong.....for me lacks something musically,it never quite lives up to expectations...so i would rate it much lower.
I understand the point Tim and Michel are making....the way people are rating things has changed greatly......even i see that and i've been a member here for a much shorter time than Tim has......
If everyone just rates everything as10/10 ...it makesthis part of the forum meaningless.......
It was a serious part of the forum where you could have proper discussions about rthe songs...what you liked about this, disliked about that.....this version was great because...etc
and rating each song on it's individual merits, gave you a list , of what were the top songs, people's all time favourites......backed up by serious discussion
Now ..if people do a blanket vote across the board of 10/10 for every song(even
IFthey genuinely feel, everysong merits a 10/10) it makes a mockery of what was established here.
just my opinion
Bren