Quote:
Originally Posted by Kathy
We all have ears to hear him sing, but only Meat himself and Eric Vetro (and any other professionals he may employ to help him care for and develop his voice) are qualified to criticise that voice.
|
So we're getting into semantics here ... and assuming that the performance and the voice are separate things, where one is qualified to criticise the performance but not the voice, if I understand you correctly ?
The two are inextricably linked surely, and its difficult to say if the performances are consistently good or bad, this doesn't reflect the condition of the voice. This is hardly a 'sweeping generalisation'.