I'm sure Meat said it was a live performance .. and that's good enough for me without analysing it to death by nanosecond. It was a GREAT performance which to me is what matters. And I've sat close enough to performances in the TV studio to hear that even on the odd occasion when Meat has been forced to use a recorded track, he doesn't "mime", but SINGS live anyway. Let's not disinter any more dead equines!
Caryl