Quote:
Originally Posted by Evil One
For arguments sake what if the clip was of excellent visual and audio quality, but Meat was poor?  |
Without backtracking, i'm going to say that that is a grey area.
Why?
Because if the vid was DVD quality, i'm talking the best, and an 100% accurate representation of his performance, then it's something that speaks for itself.
BUT......... (yes,there's a but)
There's a part of me that also feels that a bootleg (and a bootleg it would be, as is any other youtube clip) is not an
official release, and it's the work an artist releases that the artist wants to represent them.
Put it this way, so see what a painter is like, do you go to his studio or the bin round the back?
If it's an official release, I say that honest but respectful criticism is perfectly acceptable.
This thread seems to suggest that i'm trying to make mlukfc into a 100% palace of perfect positivity.
That, to be blunt, is crap.
I was not in love with everything about HCTB, and was quite vocal about my dislike.
I hate rap, I hate the raps on HIHB, and i've felt no hesitation in expressing how much I hate them.
So no, I don't think this place needs to be full of unicorns that eat ambrosia and shit rainbows.
But I do think that Meat deserves to be condemned by something better than a camera phone clip.
As a side note, I think it's strange that I feel I need to justify my thoughts by mentioning i'm not 100% in love with everything Meat has ever done.
That's sort of weird on a fan club
