OK. let me try and explain myself a little more clearly.
If somebody sees a bad quality youtube vid and sees something they like, then it does nobody any harm to say that they think it is good.
If you see a bad quality youtube vid and you don't like it, it is only fair (IMHO) and respectful not too jump to any negative conclusions (and to share those conclusions on a public forum) about the state of Meat's voice.
It prevents poorly formed opinions (and all opinions, both good and bad, are poorly formed from a youtube clip) that may (will) be offensive to Meat, and cause arguments on the forum.
Is that really so much of a problem?
I'm failing to see the 1984 in all of this.
