Quote:
Originally Posted by Adje
There is no wrong or right in giving high or low grates. Although I believe that giving 1's or 10's is always over the top.
|
Which is what I've heard so many managers say over the years .. and in effect it reduces the range used to 2-9 .. and if you make it a 2-9 scale they avoid giving nines!
Quote:
|
With a 10 you're saying "This is PERFRECT" and can't be improved in any way.
|
And as I said, if I cannot see how it could be made better for ME, then for me it requires no improvement and 10 is what I give
Quote:
But ratings like that should be rare 
|
And Meat is a rare performer in my view
BOOH was a landmark album and most of the songs I seem to recall got scores of 9+
I'm not going to fiddle around with 9.6s, or 9.75s for the sake of avoiding 10 .. For
me, HCTB and HIAH are landmark albums. So 10s seem just right
Caryl