Quote:
Originally Posted by White of High
I think give 10 to all songs is folly.
|
I agree with you on this. If all songs are a 10 to you then you can't be objective. No matter who you are.
As for low or high ratings. It's very personal. Either you love, for example, the Steinman/Loaf combination so much that other songs have a hard time to match that, or you love the way that Meat has chosen a new direction. Away from his older style.
There is no wrong or right in giving high or low grates. Although I believe that giving 1's or 10's is always over the top.
With a 1 you're basically saying that NOTHING is right about a song.
With a 10 you're saying "This is PERFRECT" and can't be improved in any way.
I doubt both ratings every time I see it. Then again, for one or two songs a rating like this could be possible. But ratings like that should be rare
