Quote:
Originally Posted by Burkeaholic
White of High tends to seemingly not like anything that isn't the Meat/Jim combo.
|
To be fair he has rated some non-Steinman songs as high as 8 and above .. even HCTB's Song of Madness rated in the nines I think. But songs seem to need a Steinman/Bat style to get real approval, and you're right imo that Meat's new style seems to have limited appeal. He has also despaired of those of us who rate anything 10
For me, if I thoroughly enjoy listening to a song and would not have it changed, it works perfectly and meets all my requirements .. so why should I not say so? I personally find grading systems will always encourage some people to never give full marks, and have never understood this. As for eg when I ask managers who have graded a piece of work 9 out of 10 what could be done or changed to improve it, they say .. "Nothing. Its great. But I never give 10s"
I do
Caryl