Personally I'd rather buy re-issues on vinyl than any other format, I think the Meat Loaf album covers lend themselves to being printed on bigger surfaces so I'd always go for vinyl because they're lovely pieces just to "have".
The other appeal with re-issues on vinyl is that because I became a fan when Bat II came out, all of my vinyls from Stoney & Meat Loaf until 1993 are second hand (apart from my fabulous limited edition Simply Vinyl copy of Bat whic is immaculate!) Bat II onwards I've managed to get hold of brand new copies but it would be nice from a collectors point of view to have new copies of the older stuff.
Note - if you arrange for re-issues of CHSIB there will be hell to pay! Keep it rare please