Caryl wrote:
Quote:
|
But Bob's voice was not what made the songs special to us, it was what they conveyed, how they reached out to us.
|
Well said Caryl. I've been a fan of Dylan for a long time. I do wonder how many people on this forum have heard Dylan sing this. For me Dylan singing this is associated with lots of good memories and I'm probably unable to judge the song objectively.
Quote:
|
Meat's voice is imo vastly superior, so judged just in terms of how the song sounds, there'd be no contest.
|
Well yes, Meat's voice is vastly superior. I did have difficultly listening to Meat sing this at first but have grown to love Meat's version.
I'm not sure I'd like to choose between the two versions. Each is associated with very different periods of my life and both are special to me.