View Full Version : Meat Loaf & Jennifer Hudson.
TheDoode
14 Feb 2011, 00:46
This is pretty cool. Never seen it before. Does anyone know if it was part of the In Search of Paradise shoot or the EPK for Bat III? Either way, Meat is having fun, they're getting the stuff down, they both sound great. Would be cool to see stuff like this in the run up to Hell In A Handbasket :cool:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2sbLWORT6E
Doode.
Evil One
14 Feb 2011, 00:50
It was part of the 'Making Of Bat 3' behind the scenes guff that came with the Bat 3 special edition. :twisted:
TheDoode
14 Feb 2011, 00:55
I vaguelly remember it now, yeah man. Still, interesting to look back after half a decade has elapsed.
Evil One
14 Feb 2011, 00:57
Just another in the seemingly endless stream of boneheaded moves involving Meat's albums. This song should have been released as a single to take full advantage of the Oscar buzz that Jennifer Hudson had surrounding her at the time. :roll:
TheDoode
14 Feb 2011, 00:59
Agreed, it's a killer track. Though the single idea would mean losing about three quarters of it for the slightest hope of getting any air play. That said ... AFL.
It was part of the 'Making Of Bat 3' behind the scenes guff that came with the Bat 3 special edition. :twisted:
No, it wasn't. Jennifer Hudson does not appear on that.
Evil One
14 Feb 2011, 01:02
I'll take your word for it. I have no desire to find my DVD and check!
duke knooby
14 Feb 2011, 01:06
i'll say the same thing i said the last time this clip was shown on this forum... its a faked promo clip
Maybe one fine day someone can answer the question I've asked before: Why was Jennifer Hudson's participation not used for promo? Everybody else was mentioned...
Paul Richardson
14 Feb 2011, 01:08
Meat scares the shit out of her when comes in with, 'Some days I feel so numb and empty...' first time around :lol:
TheDoode
14 Feb 2011, 01:21
Meat scares the shit out of her when comes in with, 'Some days I feel so numb and empty...' first time around :lol:
Awesome, isn't it :D
duke knooby
14 Feb 2011, 01:23
Awesome, isn't it :D
no
TheDoode
14 Feb 2011, 01:35
no
asphinctersayswhat?
This is pretty cool. Never seen it before. Does anyone know if it was part of the In Search of Paradise shoot or the EPK for Bat III? Either way, Meat is having fun, they're getting the stuff down, they both sound great. Would be cool to see stuff like this in the run up to Hell In A Handbasket :cool:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2sbLWORT6E
Doode.
thanks, I love it! :) I've never seen it before either. No scene from it appears on the EPK, although it was shot in the same studio.
-Kathy
Wish they didnt cut Meat's little emotional moment at 2:23.
This is pretty cool. Never seen it before. Does anyone know if it was part of the In Search of Paradise shoot or the EPK for Bat III? Either way, Meat is having fun, they're getting the stuff down, they both sound great. Would be cool to see stuff like this in the run up to Hell In A Handbasket :cool:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2sbLWORT6E
Doode.
It`s not available in Germany!:(
Smithie
14 Feb 2011, 17:23
Maybe one fine day someone can answer the question I've asked before: Why was Jennifer Hudson's participation not used for promo? Everybody else was mentioned...
Technically, Patti wasn't mentioned either. I've always liked Jennifer Hudson's voice, but I thought her vocals were dreadful on The Future.
A Slice Of English
15 Feb 2011, 22:51
Technically, Patti wasn't mentioned either. I've always liked Jennifer Hudson's voice, but I thought her vocals were dreadful on The Future.
Patti wasn't mentioned because she has no worldwide star appeal unlike those previously mentioned.
glamourgirl
16 Feb 2011, 16:01
Patti wasn't mentioned because she has no worldwide star appeal unlike those previously mentioned.
Marion had no worldwide star appeal either.
Monstro
16 Feb 2011, 16:24
Marion had no worldwide star appeal either.
Had an album to promote though
Technically, Patti wasn't mentioned either. I've always liked Jennifer Hudson's voice, but I thought her vocals were dreadful on The Future.
Agreed. I love Future and it was one of the songs I'd always hoped Meat would do, but I really don't like the Bat III version. Love Meat on it, stunning vocal from him, but I'm reaching for the Skip Track button as soon as Jennifer Hudson comes in...she has a great voice but it wasn't appropriate for this song at all, I found it way too shouty :?
glamourgirl
16 Feb 2011, 20:42
Had an album to promote though
True. It was just the wrong choice for a single. And the plan to promote Marion didn't help her career anyway.
glamourgirl
16 Feb 2011, 20:44
Agreed. I love Future and it was one of the songs I'd always hoped Meat would do, but I really don't like the Bat III version. Love Meat on it, stunning vocal from him, but I'm reaching for the Skip Track button as soon as Jennifer Hudson comes in...she has a great voice but it wasn't appropriate for this song at all, I found it way too shouty :?
That's how I felt too. It sounds like Jennifer is shouting the lyrics. No emotion whatsoever. Which is surprising because she's a really talented singer, just not the right fit for this song.
Oh I dunno, she's a judge on X Factor over there now which has gotta be a good thing (though how much of that is down to the work with Meat I don't know)
madagascar
17 Feb 2011, 00:44
Agreed. I love Future and it was one of the songs I'd always hoped Meat would do, but I really don't like the Bat III version. Love Meat on it, stunning vocal from him, but I'm reaching for the Skip Track button as soon as Jennifer Hudson comes in...she has a great voice but it wasn't appropriate for this song at all, I found it way too shouty :?
Where's Wario when you need him?;)
Come on dude we need a ''Jennifer-Hudson-is-nowhere-to-be-seen-and-heared'' Remix! :-):-)
Evil One
17 Feb 2011, 01:03
Jennifer Hudson should never have been on that song for another reason as far as I'm concerned. It's not a duet! :twisted:
Paul Richardson
17 Feb 2011, 01:18
Jennifer Hudson should never have been on that song for another reason as far as I'm concerned. It's not a duet! :twisted:
Its not a duet but Meat appears to like to turn songs that aren't into one - IACBTMN ?
It's not a duet! :twisted:
Exactly. The same goes for IACBTM. I hate to say it but I like the other versions (incl. Celine Dion's :shock:) better than Meat's. Turning those songs into duets weakened them. Maybe that obsession with duets is the curse of the success of Anything?
And why that many different duet partners? Unlike Patti, Marion Raven and Jennifer Hudson don't have much to do with Meat Loaf. The whole album did not appear like a Meat Loaf album, more than somebody else's project Meat Loaf just contributed vocals to.
Agreed. I love Future and it was one of the songs I'd always hoped Meat would do, but I really don't like the Bat III version. Love Meat on it, stunning vocal from him, but I'm reaching for the Skip Track button as soon as Jennifer Hudson comes in...she has a great voice but it wasn't appropriate for this song at all, I found it way too shouty :?
I totally agree. To me it seemed like she was trying to overpower him. As almost as if to say 'I'll show you that I can sing just as powerfully as he can'.
The whole album did not appear like a Meat Loaf album, more than somebody else's project Meat Loaf just contributed vocals to.
Yeah it was Desmond Child's project, not Meat Loaf's. He seemed to want to get his name in wherever he could.
I looked at the inlay booklet the other day and you know how the artist usually has a couple of paragraphs with their 'thank yous'? Bat III had thank yous from Desmond Child and nothing from Meat.
Miss Hudson could never out power THE LOAF:-P,, well in the end Meat explained alot about the Bat 3 project, and its been talked to death. has our dear Desmond done much since?
while we are on the subject of jen hudson, id like to point out regardless if you like her on the track or not, 2006 was her big year. if Future got single treatment maybe that would've been smart instead of taking risks with the unknown Marion Raven.
Then again that's been brought up before.
you may think im crazy with this, but I find Jen's voice very gospel-like and think it works well. I would've loved to hear her and Meat duet on Testify. if any song needs duet treatment, thats a great gospel duet right there.
To me it seemed like she was trying to overpower him.
That's what bothers me the most about the song. I hear two people scream (Jennifer Hudson more than Meat) but they don't seem to sing with each other. Just power without true emotion. The Future... actually is a fantastic song but the Bat III version is pretty annoying, in my opinion. Jennifer Hudson is an amazing singer but somehow out of place on this one.
Yeah it was Desmond Child's project, not Meat Loaf's. He seemed to want to get his name in wherever he could.
I looked at the inlay booklet the other day and you know how the artist usually has a couple of paragraphs with their 'thank yous'? Bat III had thank yous from Desmond Child and nothing from Meat.
I suspected something like that once I saw his pic in the booklet. Even in the promo trailer and "making of" you hardly see anything of Meat. It made me feel uncomfortable about the album, I always had the feeling as if there was something "wrong".
you may think im crazy with this, but I find Jen's voice very gospel-like and think it works well. I would've loved to hear her and Meat duet on Testify. if any song needs duet treatment, thats a great gospel duet right there.
That would probably work well. Although I'd rather like to hear Aretha Franklin or Tina Turner on that. Testify deserves to be played live again, by the way.
allrevvedup
17 Feb 2011, 20:14
That version is, unfortunately, not something that I even want to consider listening to.
Had it been on Bat II it might've worked with just Meat on his own, but the original version and Patti Russo's effort are far superior as far as I'm concerned.
duke knooby
17 Feb 2011, 21:35
I looked at the inlay booklet the other day and you know how the artist usually has a couple of paragraphs with their 'thank yous'? Bat III had thank yous from Desmond Child and nothing from Meat.
i assumed the dedication on the back cover of the inlay was from meat
"for 30 years of friendship and inspiration. bat out of hell III is dedicated to jim steinman"
BostonAngel
17 Feb 2011, 22:55
......That's what bothers me the most about the song. I hear two people scream (Jennifer Hudson more than Meat) but they don't seem to sing with each other. Just power without true emotion. The Future... actually is a fantastic song but the Bat III version is pretty annoying, in my opinion. Jennifer Hudson is an amazing singer but somehow out of place on this one.........
I pretty much agree with this! To be honest, I didn't think that Meat and Jennifer were even in the same studio recording this song until I saw the video. It sounded as if he recorded his version, she recorded her part and then they were mixed together in the studio. I think The Future is an awesome song. I think Jennifer Hudson is a talented and powerful singer. It just didn't quite all come together on the recording of this song.
duke knooby
18 Feb 2011, 00:38
anyway, dug out the original posters video... and i'll make it very clear i have absolutely no idea what happened in the studio, so the following is nothing more than my possible misguided opinion...
it seems pretty clear to me from the clip, they are not recording anything, just miming to an already completed recording, purely for promotional reasons... hence my lack of awe to the video...
ive no idea if both vocalists recorded at the same time in the same studio, or not.
what is known (ish), is which organisation put it on the tube, when they did it, and what they called it...
and here it is..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdCiZsbrsXQ
you may think im crazy with this, but I find Jen's voice very gospel-like and think it works well.
Then I'm crazy with you, WarieL, because I feel similar. It' my favorite song on the album and Bat 3 is still my favorite Bat. It suited me for my age then and still does. It's in the rotation of meatie albums I take with me to listen to at work. In fact, I think I'll take them along with me today ... :D ...
OH and ps, I bothers me no end that whenever I've seen JH anywhere in interview, I've never heard her mention Meat. Maybe she did and I missed it ? Has any one ever heard her mention him ? As a Meat fan, that bothers me.
Smithie
18 Feb 2011, 18:02
This song is a good example of why guest artists rarely work. Just because someone is a great singer does not mean her/his voice will sound great next to Meat's voice. I would love to hear a solo version of this song by Meat or a version with Meat and Patti.
Then I'm crazy with you, WarieL, because I feel similar.
So do I .. I think that "gospel" sound fits the song perfectly, and it's one of my favourite tracks as well. To me it's two strong voices matching each other well with passion packed into it. Love it :D
Caryl
So do I .. I think that "gospel" sound fits the song perfectly, and it's one of my favourite tracks as well. To me it's two strong voices matching each other well with passion packed into it. Love it :D
Caryl
I agree, i love the Gospel sound on the song, its part of the appeal for me, i think it is one great duet, personal tastes i guess.
I agree, i love the Gospel sound on the song, its part of the appeal for me, i think it is one great duet, personal tastes i guess.
I second that.
I agree with the gospel thing, and I like the gospel, but for me it could just do with toning down a little. We know Jennifer has a powerful voice but I think in this case less would have been more. In my opinion.
Pudding
19 Feb 2011, 22:05
I'm agreeing with the gospel thingy, but for it to work properly then it needs to be just Jennifer, as she does gospel and Meat doesn't. Would love to hear a solo effort from her.
Evil One
19 Feb 2011, 22:08
I don't necessarily agree with that. I thought Testify was pretty shit hot. Jennifer Hudson doing the Future solo would probably be similar to the Pandora's Box version, so why try to duplicate excellence? I'd rather hear Patti's version with full instrumentation. :twisted:
Yes, Meat did a great gospel sound in Testify! He can not only act the ass off a gospel preacher role .. he has a great voice for a gospel type song, and Testify was marvellous.
Caryl
Testify was great, Testify live with MSO...immense, that version is stunning!
The Flying Mouse
19 Feb 2011, 22:30
:twisted: He does a mean American Trillogy too 8)
Pudding
19 Feb 2011, 22:33
Apart from Elvis, not many white singers can do gospel justice. And apart from the beginning bit of Testify, I'd say the song is anything but gospel.
That's your view. Not the view of some of us. Pointless to argue the toss.
Pudding
19 Feb 2011, 22:59
Yes it is and here you are arguing the toss over my opinion..WTF? :wtf:
pringled
19 Feb 2011, 23:02
i love to see people recording
stretch37
19 Feb 2011, 23:07
i love to see people recording
totally agree with u pringled. Im glad the video was reposted, reminded me how awesome it is watching Meat record, especially because he sounds so great.:-)
Yes it is and here you are arguing the toss over my opinion..WTF? :wtf:
No .. I merely said you disagree, whilst some of us think Meat sings gospel well. Different opinions. I accept yours is different, and I wouldn't waste my air trying to argue or change it. Agree to dsagree. So please don't "What the F***" me. It's rude.
Caryl
He can not only act the ass off a gospel preacher role [...] and Testify was marvellous.
I agree with Caryl. :shock: Especially the MSO version has some nice gospel and blues elements, I'd like to hear Meat do more of that kind.
BostonAngel
20 Feb 2011, 05:15
Yes, Meat did a great gospel sound in Testify! He can not only act the ass off a gospel preacher role .. he has a great voice for a gospel type song, and Testify was marvellous.
Caryl
I agree with Caryl. :shock: Especially the MSO version has some nice gospel and blues elements, I'd like to hear Meat do more of that kind.
I agree with both of you!
Julie in the rv mirror
20 Feb 2011, 07:18
I'm agreeing with the gospel thingy, but for it to work properly then it needs to be just Jennifer, as she does gospel and Meat doesn't. Would love to hear a solo effort from her.
001uGO4GDzU
glamourgirl
22 Feb 2011, 20:08
Patti wasn't mentioned because she has no worldwide star appeal unlike those previously mentioned.
To Meat Loaf fans worldwide, she has star appeal. I think she deserves just as much acknowledgment and respect, maybe more, because of her huge contribution to Meat's albums and tours all these years.
Pudding
23 Feb 2011, 05:36
To Meat Loaf fans worldwide, she has star appeal. I think she deserves just as much acknowledgment and respect, maybe more, because of her huge contribution to Meat's albums and tours all these years.
Patti isn't recognised worldwide, that shouldn't even be debated, it would be nice if she was but she isn't. And I believe Patti is respected, to suggest she deserves respect would indicate she isn't respected, which is utter nonsense.
@Julie - cheers for the clip, I hadn't seen it before. Jennifer doing Testify full gospel would be awesome.
vBulletin® v3.8.10, Copyright ©2000-2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.