Westlife - Total Eclipse of the Heart - Page 3

LucyK! · 26 Jan 2007, 19:43

Goodness, how heated has this become!!

I imagine it probably will go to number 1 purely because it's Westlife, they could sing nursery rhymes and they'd go to number 1, which is a great shame.

But hey, they're a band who are at the minute doing a range of cover versions, they've been given a song, it's going to get them a hellof a lot of publicity and even more cash - can't blame the boys really

JanT · 26 Jan 2007, 19:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by THE FLYING MOUSE

As I say, not brilliant, but under the circumstances, not bad for a first ever shot at singing it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mszee

http://www.mlukfc.com/forums/showpos...46&postcount=1

Thank you both

I like it and have downloaded it for keeps.

**RadioMaster** · 26 Jan 2007, 20:01

you´re right Lucy, that´s the real shame.
that thing will reach #1, and as song as BAAB will be lucky to be found in the top 5

MeatGrl1 · 26 Jan 2007, 20:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by RadioMaster

YouTube Video

Think I´ll lay down and die now....

This is wrong on so many levels !!!!

That dancing... don't get me started

!

evil nickname · 26 Jan 2007, 21:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lucy!

Goodness, how heated has this become!!

From the viscousness of some comments, you'd imagine someone said something bad about a Meat Loaf song (the horror!)

In fact, I'm appalled by the utter ridiculousness of some of the comments. If you don't like a cover of song, fine. You don't have to listen to it anymore, and just move on!
Repeatedly calling the performers of said cover various names (f*cking assholes, for example) is just plain silly and wrong. Especially by a moderator.

Could we get another mod in here to give some people a chill pill?

*AndyK* · 26 Jan 2007, 21:09

It's already been done ... consider the thread brought back on topic.

Sapphire Lady · 26 Jan 2007, 21:19

Goodness what a great thread I've started here

I didn't think the Westlife version was too horrific (although I did cringe at the end part). There's obviously a market for this type of stuff - people will like it and people will buy it.

I'm just away to e-mail Gary Barlow and suggest Take That do You Took The Words

**RadioMaster** · 26 Jan 2007, 21:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sapphire Lady

Goodness what a great thread I've started here

I didn't think the Westlife version was too horrific (although I did cringe at the end part). There's obviously a market for this type of stuff - people will like it and people will buy it.

I'm just away to e-mail Gary Barlow and suggest Take That do You Took The Words

Why not Objects or for crying out loud?

lorenzoduke · 26 Jan 2007, 21:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by THE FLYING MOUSE

STEINMAN IS INVOLVED WITH THIS MONSTOSITY?????????????

WTF?

Jesus tapdancing Christ, Jim Steinman working with shitelife.

Someone tell me i'd had my drink spiked and this is just a real bad trip.

Thank God the Tanz intro was spared.

I'd NEVER have forgiven him for putting that on a westknobjockeys record.

Talk about a sell out

Well, he was involved with Boyzone 10 years back.

Still, at least he chose not to be involved with Bat III - that would have really tarnished his legacy.

Did I say that?

djfierce · 26 Jan 2007, 22:00

hmm so we cant have an opinion on any songs but meat's? interesting

i think the fact Steinman was/wasnt/could've been involved in this has clouded some peoples objective judgment skills

and it is more than just this song..they have done it quite alot which implies money making gimmick, can we not have an opinion on that either?

*AndyK* · 26 Jan 2007, 22:05

Don't think anyones said you can't have an opinion ... it's more a question of how that opinion is voiced that was the issue!

djfierce · 26 Jan 2007, 22:08

maybe i misread a certain post then..if so i apologise

disregard the first part of my post

but i stand by the rest

Pudding · 26 Jan 2007, 23:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by THE FLYING MOUSE

It's self serving crap with little or no purpose, and it's sole purpose is to put money in some suit pocket.

A bit like IACBTMN then on Bat3

Although Westlife's version isn't the best by far, it certainly isn't the worse. I can't get my head around this song being sung just by the lads and no lasses, one could argue that it is though

Pud

Pudding · 26 Jan 2007, 23:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by mszee

Didn't like it...in fact, had to listen to Bonnie's version 10 times over just to get bad taste out of my mouth...

What were you doing with Westlife in your mouth?

Pud

wizardofodd · 26 Jan 2007, 23:31

not as criminal as re-doing "i have a dream" but still not good. never mind some boy band would have to remake it at some point.
Bonnie performed total eclipse on This Morning yesturday live. maybe this is to remind the public audience she did it origionaly.

Pudding · 26 Jan 2007, 23:40

Yep, I Have A Dream was painful.

Pud

mszee · 26 Jan 2007, 23:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pudding

What were you doing with Westlife in your mouth?

Pud

Oh hon...unless you're 5 years old...you know VERY WELL what I was doing...

mszee · 26 Jan 2007, 23:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by wizardofodd

not as criminal as re-doing "i have a dream" but still not good. never mind some boy band would have to remake it at some point.
Bonnie performed total eclipse on This Morning yesturday live. maybe this is to remind the public audience she did it origionaly.

Isn't it coming out re-mixed or something? I hear it a lot on the radio now...not such a great version...but still Bonnie...

*AndyK* · 27 Jan 2007, 00:37

Bonnie re-re-re-release of TEOTH is a collaboration with Baby Pink Star.

christa · 29 Jan 2007, 23:51

Well I've seen Westlife 5 times in concert and do you know what? they are actually quite entertaining and fun. Each to their own eh? And I wouldn't mind 10 minutes alone with that Shane! Corrrrrrrrrrr

**RadioMaster** · 30 Jan 2007, 12:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by christabales

And I wouldn't mind 10 minutes alone with that Shane! Corrrrrrrrrrr

Me neither.
*gets out the BIG knife"

Ageing Bat · 30 Jan 2007, 12:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by christabales

Well I've seen Westlife 5 times in concert and do you know what? they are actually quite entertaining and fun. Each to their own eh?

I quite agree Christa! The concert we saw was very well done - they had a 'glass' stage that come down over the front half of the audience so that those at the back got a better view for part of the concert.

djfierce · 30 Jan 2007, 14:17

i'm sorry but they're full of gimmicks and other peoples music

Betty · 30 Jan 2007, 14:34

I´ve just heard the song performed by them for the first time...
And I have to admit that I don´t like it.
That has nothing to do with the band itself, because I like some songs of them.

It´s just, you can´t cover THAT song... It just won´t work in my opinion.
I love the song performed by Bonnie Tyler, it´s so unbelievably great!!!

I wouldn´t say they´ve destroyed the song, but it just doesn´t touch me at all!!!

**Monstro** · 30 Jan 2007, 15:02

Guess I really should make the effort to listen to this

26 Jan 2007, 19:43	#51
LucyK! The Monster Is Luce Join Date: 14.04.2002 Location: Posts: 7,547	Goodness, how heated has this become!! I imagine it probably will go to number 1 purely because it's Westlife, they could sing nursery rhymes and they'd go to number 1, which is a great shame. But hey, they're a band who are at the minute doing a range of cover versions, they've been given a song, it's going to get them a hellof a lot of publicity and even more cash - can't blame the boys really

26 Jan 2007, 20:01	#53
RadioMaster The German Join Date: 11.03.2006 Location: some kind of hunting lodge for rich weirdos... Posts: 15,778	you´re right Lucy, that´s the real shame. that thing will reach #1, and as song as BAAB will be lucky to be found in the top 5

26 Jan 2007, 21:09	#56
AndyK Relentless Join Date: 21.11.2003 Location: Over the top..... seeing what's on the other side Posts: 18,694	It's already been done ... consider the thread brought back on topic.

26 Jan 2007, 21:19	#57
Sapphire Lady Mega Loafer Join Date: 21.04.2003 Location: Scotland Posts: 1,213	Goodness what a great thread I've started here I didn't think the Westlife version was too horrific (although I did cringe at the end part). There's obviously a market for this type of stuff - people will like it and people will buy it. I'm just away to e-mail Gary Barlow and suggest Take That do You Took The Words

26 Jan 2007, 22:00	#60
djfierce Mega Loafer Join Date: 15.06.2005 Location: Posts: 3,596	hmm so we cant have an opinion on any songs but meat's? interesting i think the fact Steinman was/wasnt/could've been involved in this has clouded some peoples objective judgment skills and it is more than just this song..they have done it quite alot which implies money making gimmick, can we not have an opinion on that either?

26 Jan 2007, 22:05	#61
AndyK Relentless Join Date: 21.11.2003 Location: Over the top..... seeing what's on the other side Posts: 18,694	Don't think anyones said you can't have an opinion ... it's more a question of how that opinion is voiced that was the issue!

26 Jan 2007, 22:08	#62
djfierce Mega Loafer Join Date: 15.06.2005 Location: Posts: 3,596	maybe i misread a certain post then..if so i apologise disregard the first part of my post but i stand by the rest

26 Jan 2007, 23:31	#65
wizardofodd Super Loafer Join Date: 14.11.2004 Location: London Posts: 412	not as criminal as re-doing "i have a dream" but still not good. never mind some boy band would have to remake it at some point. Bonnie performed total eclipse on This Morning yesturday live. maybe this is to remind the public audience she did it origionaly.

26 Jan 2007, 23:40	#66
Pudding I'm A Prize Fight Lover... Join Date: 22.10.2003 Location: New Zealand Posts: 5,532	Yep, I Have A Dream was painful. Pud

27 Jan 2007, 00:37	#69
AndyK Relentless Join Date: 21.11.2003 Location: Over the top..... seeing what's on the other side Posts: 18,694	Bonnie re-re-re-release of TEOTH is a collaboration with Baby Pink Star.

29 Jan 2007, 23:51	#70
christa Super Loafer Join Date: 23.05.2003 Location: Nottingham Posts: 663	Well I've seen Westlife 5 times in concert and do you know what? they are actually quite entertaining and fun. Each to their own eh? And I wouldn't mind 10 minutes alone with that Shane! Corrrrrrrrrrr

30 Jan 2007, 14:17	#73
djfierce Mega Loafer Join Date: 15.06.2005 Location: Posts: 3,596	i'm sorry but they're full of gimmicks and other peoples music

30 Jan 2007, 14:34	#74
Betty ˙·٠•● ♫ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ♪ ●•٠·˙ Join Date: 12.11.2006 Location: Niedersachsen Posts: 6,387	I´ve just heard the song performed by them for the first time... And I have to admit that I don´t like it. That has nothing to do with the band itself, because I like some songs of them. It´s just, you can´t cover THAT song... It just won´t work in my opinion. I love the song performed by Bonnie Tyler, it´s so unbelievably great!!! I wouldn´t say they´ve destroyed the song, but it just doesn´t touch me at all!!!

30 Jan 2007, 15:02	#75
Monstro Promoted to Wario's spellchecker Join Date: 17.09.2005 Location: London Posts: 12,945	Guess I really should make the effort to listen to this